⚡ EV Life Club

Comparison of the day

Volkswagen ID.5 2022 vs Tesla Model Y 2022 vs Volkswagen ID.4 2026 vs Škoda Superb 2017: cost of owning over 5 years

🇵🇹 Portugal · 15,000 km a year · 5 years · calculated 2026-10-27

Volkswagen ID.5 2022 costs €2,672 less over 5 years.
CarTotalPer monthPer kmBought forWorth at the end
Volkswagen ID.5 2022
used, 80,000 km
€20,427€340€0.27€22,000€12,704
Tesla Model Y 2022
used, 80,000 km
€23,099€385€0.31€27,000€15,591
Volkswagen ID.4 2026
new
€25,651€428€0.34€27,000€14,429
Škoda Superb 2017
used, 270,000 km
€29,316€489€0.39€10,000€5,170

What the money goes on

Volkswagen ID.5 2022Tesla Model Y 2022Volkswagen ID.4 2026Škoda Superb 2017
Depreciation€9,296€11,409€12,571€4,830
Energy€6,261€5,911€5,981€10,187
Servicing€468€479€231€1,055
Repairs€1,768€2,529€411€8,561
Major failures€102€158€16€627
Battery risk€83€81€0€0
Tyres€1,093€1,167€531€347
Insurance€1,301€1,301€5,855€1,821
Taxes€0€0€0€1,821
One-offs€55€65€55€65
Total€20,427€23,099€25,651€29,316

What the club's analyst says

For your circumstances, switching from the Superb to the Volkswagen ID.5 is preferable if diagnostics confirm the battery’s condition and no serious faults: it combines lower depreciation with lower running costs. Keeping the Superb becomes more compelling if major expensive components have already been replaced and your service history confirms a substantially lower repair need than the model assumes.

The ID.5’s main advantage is its relatively low purchase price, with lower expected energy and repair costs than the Superb with 270 thousand km. The Tesla is slightly more economical, but costs more to buy and has known costly weak points outside the general warranty. The new ID.4 offers warranty protection, but loses out on depreciation and the assumed insurance coverage; the insurance comparison is not yet like-for-like. With 55% of charging away from home, EVs require substantially more of your time: about 84 hours for the Tesla, 87 for the ID.5 and 96 for the ID.4, versus 27 hours for the Superb over five years. Battery age, chemistry and active warranties are already accounted for in the source model, so no additional battery-risk adjustment is made without diagnostics.

What decides it

Calculate with your own numbersThe full reportDiscuss in the club's channel

How it is calculated

The price, what the car is still worth at the end, energy at the country's prices, servicing, repairs and the risk of big failures, tyres, insurance and taxes — for the mileage and years above. The AI looks up the cars' data; the sums are made by the calculator itself, the same way for every car. Prices are those of the day of the calculation.

More comparisons